Aarin is bluffing :/ THG is not the paranoid, or one of our detectives would have exploded when checking him. Even so, they'd hit him with the Godfather and absorb his counter hit.
The known sleeper roles we've seen die are paramedic, vigilante, serial killer, (any that I missed), stands to reason the last sleepers are detective, gossiper, +1 other - and I doubt it's another paramedic.
I also don't think there's a mad hatter anywhere in the game :D
I gave Aarin our list of suspicious cats, which was Malice-sama, Jun, SpiritClaw16 and Shadowblade Edge. In return, he sent us (apparently) the town list.
NeoNostalgia (mafia)
Zaxser (mafia)
Eyolo (mafia)
Malice (TFG).
There are kill clues that point to NeoNostalgia as the piper, and Zaxser as the wolf. I'm not sure how Eyolo's name got added to the mix except through Squidworth's commentary. Of the remaining mafia roles, only two have kill power - if the town lynches one and we deadvote the other, they'll have 0 kill power tonight.
So we just need to deadvote one of the mafia's with kill power. I don't see any clues pointing towards Shadowblade so that would make him the storyteller, have no kill power, and one of the town picks for mafia (Neo/Zaxser/Eyolo) is wrong.
They had no information on the siblings up until DJROC's observation about SpiritClaw16.
However, here's the problem: That detective check BBC made said that THG, Malice or SpiritClaw16 were mafia. Townies think Malice is TFG. What do they know about SpiritClaw that makes him not seen as mafia?
TheHumbleGrasshopper raised an interesing point in chat - he didn't pardon BBC, whom he knew to be a detective, from the lynch. I assume this was because up until the lynch, Roxy was voting for Zero_Kanipan and he was two votes up; Roxy's removal from the game meant BBC was up next.
The trouble is we have three too many names.
Zaxser - mafia wolf?
NeoNostalgia OR Eyolo - mafia piper?
Malice-Sama OR SpiritClaw16 OR Shadowedge Blade - mafia storyteller.
Out of Zax, Neo, Malice, Spirit, Eyolo and Shadow, only three of those are mafia. If the town is right, and Malice is TFG, Spirit MUST be the third mafia (...unless THG really IS mafia O_o).
If we also trust that Zero really didn't sell us a bridge, that means either Zaxser or NeoNostalgia are innocent.
I am really not convinced on the argument for Neo and he gave a good account for himself previously, whereas up until now all the other mafia accused simply folded. I also am not sold for Eyolo either...except that he has a really creepy guy in the background of his myspace - http://www.myspace.com/serenityapocolypse There is a song playing too but I don't know the name of it so I can't check the lyrics :/ It's not a long stretch of the imagination to have Eyolo as the piper.
I'm not sure what I'm going to do yet. I'll see if WonderChicken (I sent him a dead invite) has anything to add for us...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
THG couldn't have pardoned BBC if the haunt vote blocks that ability. We may have ourselves to blame for that :(
I suspect the 3 mafia are NeoNostalgia (threat to the necro), Shadowedge (Zero's statement and he's the storyteller), and SpiritClaw16 (vote and suspect claims).
I say we haunt Spiritclaw because if he's not mafia he's gotta be a sibling.
Oh oops >.> That's true. I never considered that...
Well something doesn't add up.
The list that Aarin gave me had Neo, Zax, Eyolo and Malice. THG had the names of Malice-Sama OR SpiritClaw16 as mafia...which makes me think Aarin's list is not from THG, or was edited in some way.
Remember, Aarin can't win with the townies, but he CAN win with mafia.
Even if SpiritClaw is mafia, there are no clues pointing to him so far, he doesn't have kill power. Since the town is going to lynch Neo, I'm putting the vote in for Zaxser - hopefully it will knock out the mafia kill power tonight.
Post a Comment